Confusion Regarding Using Fuggles for Aroma

[JustARogue]

I'm a little confused about using Fuggles as a aroma hop. On one hand I've read that Fuggles adds grassy accents, but on the other grassy flavors are a sign of something gone wrong. How is a balance struck here?

Side note: Still being green at this, I'm currently reading "How to Brew" with "Designing Great Beers" next on the list. Will DGB cover this?

 

[Grizzlybrew]

There is a great chapter on hops with plenty of info on hop oils and their characteristics in DGB (btw - one of the best books I've read). I'm not sure if he talks specifically about grassy smells.

I've always thought of fuggles as earthy or as a fellow brewer describes, dirt.

 

[Schnitzengiggle]

Fuggles are "earthy" which is a flavor/aroma I am particular to. Fuggles are also considered a noble variety, although they are not a true noble hop.

 

[Yooper]

Yeah, I always think of fuggles as "dirt" tasting. As you can tell, I'm not a fan. Some say "earthy" or "grassy". I think it tastes more like dirt would taste if I put it in my boil.

"Grassy" to me means more like fresh cut grass. A definite "green" note to it.

 

[niquejim]

It's all about what you like. I love Fuggles in an ESB and it's obvious Yoop doesn't.
It's the same as me saying Simcoe smells like cat pee while others love it.

If you have the ability to split it and only dry hop 1/2 you'll be able to taste the difference yourself

 

[Grizzlybrew]

It's the same as me saying Simcoe smells like cat pee while others love it.

Don't forget about Clusters! ( I mean, I've never actually smelled cat puke covered in cat pee, but...)