Can I condition in the carboy?

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

OkanaganMike

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2015
Messages
781
Reaction score
87
Location
West Kelowna
First off, I may not have the term correct so apologies if the title is misrepresenting my question. I have only so many bottles and some of the recipes I see require longer conditioning to age or ripen the beer ie Porters etc. My question is since I have extra carboys, can a guy make ahead a beer that requires an extended amount of time required before drinking; and condition it in the carboy, with the final step of adding sugar and bottling 3 weeks before you want to drink?
Does this make sense or do you have to add the sugar and let it condition in the bottle/keg for the required extended time?
 
Sure you can condition in a carboy. The only bits you have to worry about are

1) Very extended times (many months) and you may run in to slow to carbonate/failure to carbonate issues if you loose enough yeast (yeast half life at cellar temps is around 2 months IIRC). This has never been an issue for me, though I think the longest I've cellared a beer was a RIS that sat in the carboy around 3 1/2 months before I bottled it. It carbed up in less than 3 weeks.

2) Very extended times can also raise the risk of oxygenation or other problems. Again, not overly likely to occur, but it is at least possible.

3) You'll probably still need some bottle/keg conditioning time no matter how long you condition it in the carboy. Especially bottling you have to wait for the yeast to eat up the bottling sugar, carb the beer and settle down. It isn't much sugar that the yeast is eating, but every single beer I've ever brewed has taken at LEAST 3-4 weeks after brewing to hit its peak (often times more like 5-8 weeks, though some heavier beers have taken months before I thought they had hit a peak. Though peaking doesn't mean it gets bad suddenly, might take months before I notice it isn't as good as it once was). Where I "aged" a nut brown for 8 weeks in the carboy before bottling of bottled a porter after 3 weeks. Always seems to take 1-2 weeks after the beer is properly carbed before it settles down and is its best.

Of course with some brews that require extended aging to hit their peak, it was only around 4 weeks or so before it was well conditioned, because I left it in the carboy for a couple of months first, instead of probably needing to have bottle conditioned for 2-3 months first (or longer).
 
Thanks Azazel. I figure if I can do all/most/some conditioning by leaving a batch in a 5 gal secondary for a few more weeks say after 2-3 weeks of being in the primary, it'll free up some of the bottles for regular enjoyment.
 
Thanks Azazel. I figure if I can do all/most/some conditioning by leaving a batch in a 5 gal secondary for a few more weeks say after 2-3 weeks of being in the primary, it'll free up some of the bottles for regular enjoyment.

That will work just fine. :mug:

As soon as it off yeast cake autolysis should not be a big problem.
 
Back
Top