You will have to let me know how your yeast selection turns out, I think I might try WLP008 next. I got until June-July to figure it out.
Alright...here's a re-cap:
2.5 lb Wheat DME
2.5 lb Pale Malt (2 Row)
1.25 lb Un-malted Wheat
.10 ounce Bravo
.15 ounce Magnum
Wyeast American Wheat Yeast
I mashed the Pale and Wheat @ 150 degrees for 35 minutes. Added DME and boiled. Added hops. Boiled for 60 minutes. Pitched yeast @ 75 degrees.
Target OG was 1.042 and I got 1.039. I obviously didn't get much efficiency on my mash.
Fermented in primary (no secondary) for two weeks. Kegged and under pressure for cold conditioning right now.
The samples I've tried are underwhelming. I think I'm in the ballpark but I have to tell you the beer is nearly tastless. I mean literally it almost tastes like water. It's not too sweet so I did get some bittering out of the hops I used but there is something missing.
The previous batch I did with California Ale was way wrong. The American Wheat yeast seems to be closer but really lacks the flavor profile.
What I'm going to try next:
Increase Pale Malt to 3.0 lbs
Substitute malted wheat for un-malted wheat
Increase the IBUs ever-so-slightly (they claim 13 but I may not be getting good efficiency out of mine so I may be a little short)
Also seriously considering pitching both American Wheat AND British Ale yeast. I'm convinced that their 'house yeast' is a combination of some kind. Both brewers told me to use American Wheat but their beer has a flavor twist to it that can only be created by the yeast used since they only use bittering hops.