All I get is foam...

[DoubleFisted]

I force carbonated my beer and then let it settle for 24 hours. However all I get is foam from the beer. I set the regulator at 12 psi, backed it down to 8 and it still is all foam. I just replaced the beer line and it is about 4 foot long. Does it need to be longer? What are my options here it is really pissing me off I cannot try this beer, this is a new recipe and have been eager to try it.

 

[camiller]

What procedure did you follow for force carbing.

All of my beer lines are 8 foot long of 3/16" Inside Diameter beverage line.

 

[rycov]

the beer's probably over carbed. vent the keg and let it sit for a while then hook it back up at twelve and see whats up. if it still foams you could try it again. thats what i'd do.

 

[stratslinger]

Knowing nothing else about your setup, my very first instinct is to tell you that 4' is definitely too short for a beer line. Mine are 8' and seem to work well, I've got a buddy with 5' lines who often has problems with foam.

But it'd be helpful to know more about your force carbonation process; you say that you force carbed it then let it settle for 24 hours - what exactly did you do to force carb it? Did you introduce high pressure for a few days? Just once? What temperature is the keg currently sitting at? What temp was it during force-carbonation?

Temperature will play a huge role in how well the CO2 stays in solution in the beer; the time you took to force it will also play a large role.

 

[DoubleFisted]

I have my kegs at about 40 degrees. I am thinking I will have to go to the hardware store and switch out the lines because it is probably too short of a hose I wasn't really thinking about that I was thinking of conserving space inside my kegerator. Also I have force carbed this way before and everything went well...I hook up the gas to my corny keg to the liquid out port and set it on the floor and agitate it for awhile, usually until i cannot hear any more "hissing" I set the psi to 40. When it was done I bleed the valve to relieve some pressure, set it back in the kegerator. Waited 24 hours and then bleed it off completely, and hooked up 12 psi to it.

 

[kmat123]

I agree that your beverage lines are probably too short. I would recommend 10 feet of 3/16" lines. That's what I have in my keezer and have never run into any foaming problems.

 

[SpanishCastleAle]

Agree about the line being too short. But if you really want a beer just bleed of the pressure until it pours without too much foam. If you didn't WAY overcarb it there should be some low pressure setting that will give you a decent pour.

 

[ThatGuyRyan]

When you force carbonate your beer it will take more than just a day to balance out. I usually force for 2-3 days at 25-30psi depending on the beer and temperature. Then I drop it down to 8-10psi and bleed it off once or twice a day for the next two to three days. If you really really forced it too much once you lower the PSI from the high setting don’t reconnect it. Just bleed the keg (don’t release all the gas just most) once or twice a day without adding more gas for a day or two then put the gas back on at serving pressure or just under for a few days until it evens out. Once you force a few kegs you will get a feel for how long and how much gas to use it just takes a bit of practice.

As for the beer line I have lines from 6ft to 12ft and can balance them all with time, patience and a dual zone system. But If you can I would get longer hoses or use the cure for the short hose inserts. Balancing my 6ft line takes my serving pressure down a bit lower than I would like so I use if for low carbonated beers but try to highly carbonate a beer with that line is possible but the pours are not easy or pretty.

 

[Mike_A]

Agreed with the aboves - get 8 feet of line and make sure it's 3/16" inner diameter. 1/4" or bigger lines will definitely promote foaming, regardless if you have 4 feet or 12 feet. There's also the fix of sticking an epoxy mixing spiral into the liquid side dip tube, but I had mixed results with that.

I use 8' of 3/16" line and I still serve around 5-8psi after carbing at 15-21psi, anything over 10 seems excessive.

 

[bruin_ale]

Before you switch out the lines, you can lower your serving pressure to 8psi and see if that does it. Since beer line is about 2psi resistance per foot, you should see that the foam goes away at that pressure. If that's the case, then you've proven that the beer lines need to be longer.

 

[wildwest450]

I use 8' of 3/16" line and I still serve around 5-8psi after carbing at 15-21psi, anything over 10 seems excessive.

Not only does that promote foam, but will also de-carbonate your beer.
Also, don't play with your pressure, lots of erroneous advice in this thread.


_

 

[bruin_ale]

Not sure how that would promote foam.. I've lowered my psi to bottle before to keep CO2 in solution - no foaming at all. In any case, you can serve at whatever pressure you want - but I agree you should store your beer at the proper pressure for the level of carbonation you want.

 

[rycov]

Not only does that promote foam, but will also de-carbonate your beer.
Also, don't play with your pressure, lots of erroneous advice in this thread.


_

good point. i can understand the desire to carb quickly though. my first time kegging i posted a lot on here asking how to do it. but ever since then i just do the set and forget thing. set it at serving pressure (about 12.5 for me) and leave it alone. it will get there. plus it gives my beer a little time to cold condition. my beer is definitely better for it.

 

[wildwest450]

good point. i can understand the desire to carb quickly though. my first time kegging i posted a lot on here asking how to do it. but ever since then i just do the set and forget thing. set it at serving pressure (about 12.5 for me) and leave it alone. it will get there. plus it gives my beer a little time to cold condition. my beer is definitely better for it.

Smart man.


_

 

[bruin_ale]

good point. i can understand the desire to carb quickly though. my first time kegging i posted a lot on here asking how to do it. but ever since then i just do the set and forget thing. set it at serving pressure (about 12.5 for me) and leave it alone. it will get there. plus it gives my beer a little time to cold condition. my beer is definitely better for it.

I wish I had that kind of patience. I usually do a day at 30psi, then drop to the proper pressure for the style. Cuts a couple days off the total time.

 

[wildwest450]

Not sure how that would promote foam.. I've lowered my psi to bottle before to keep CO2 in solution - no foaming at all. In any case, you can serve at whatever pressure you want - but I agree you should store your beer at the proper pressure for the level of carbonation you want.

Carbonation depends on 2 factors, temp and c02 pressure. If your beer is at 40f like the op, 12 psi will give you 2.5 volumes of c02, an average carb for ales. If you drop the pessure to serve, the co2 will break out of suspension and cause foaming. Check your lines if their NOT 100% bubble free, you will have problems. Constantly serving at lower pressures that carbonated at will eventually result in flat beer.

Line length has VERY little to do with anything. I serve out of 3 different setups, all with 5-6ft of line, never excessive foam. The op simply overcarbonated, now nothing but time to bleed off the excess c02 until he finds equilibrium, will stop the foam.

_

 

[bruin_ale]

Okay, I see what you're saying. Perhaps since we're drawing off the bottom of the keg I don't see that foam making it into whatever I'm serving into. BTW, 5-6ft of line is perfect for 12psi so obviously you don't have excessive foam.
4ft is a little short, so his primary problem could be overcarbonation but 4 feet is only enough beer line to balance 8psi depending on the resistance of the beerline he's using.

 

[SpanishCastleAle]

Line length has VERY little to do with anything. I serve out of 3 different setups, all with 5-6ft of line, never excessive foam. The op simply overcarbonated, now nothing but time to bleed off the excess c02 until he finds equilibrium, will stop the foam.

_

Can you clarify that statement? Line length (as well as ID and the smoothness of the walls) certainly has a LOT to do with serving beer from kegs. On my system; and using the 3/16" ID bev-line I use, 6 feet of line is not nearly enough to serve at 12-13 psi and 38*-39* F. Way too fast and way too much foam.

EDIT: I'm not doubting the statement of how much line you use...just that line length has very little to with anything.

 

[bruin_ale]

Can you clarify that statement? Line length (as well as ID and the smoothness of the walls) certainly has a LOT to do with serving beer from kegs. On my system; and using the 3/16" ID bev-line I use, 6 feet of line is not nearly enough to serve at 12-13 psi and 38*-39* F. Way too fast and way too much foam.

EDIT: I'm not doubting the statement of how much line you use...just that line length has very little to with anything.

Agree... a friend of mine bought a kegerator at costco that had about two feet of beer line running from the keg to the tower, he called me up in a panic saying he couldn't get anything but foam. I went over there, swapped out the tubing for a 6 foot tube and all was right with the world. This was all with his CO2 set at the proper pressure for keeping the beer at the correct carbonation level.

 

[wildwest450]

It's just that line length is used as a crutch on here a lot to solve foaming problems, which won't work. I keep all my kegerators at 42F, and can pour easily at 14-15 psi with properly carbonated beer. Now mind you, that's a fast pour.

If you know your system and how to properly carb, I have no issue to use line length to slow a pour. It just gets thrown out as a cure all to foam problems, when it really isn't.

I would also agree that 5-6ft, should be a minimum line length.


-

 

[SpanishCastleAle]

It's just that line length is used as a crutch on here a lot to solve foaming problems, which won't work. I keep all my kegerators at 42F, and can pour easily at 14-15 psi with properly carbonated beer. Now mind you, that's a fast pour.

If you know your system and how to properly carb, I have no issue to use line length to slow a pour. It just gets thrown out as a cure all to foam problems, when it really isn't.

I would also agree that 5-6ft, should be a minimum line length.


-

OK, gotcha. Maybe there are different levels of smoothness of the inner walls of bevline? I can get away with 10' but it's a bit too fast so I go with 12'.

I see other's say they can get away with 5'-6' but with my system and the bevline I use, I can't use lines that short (~39* F and 12-13 psi).

Earlier you said 'If you drop the pessure to serve, the co2 will break out of suspension and cause foaming.' which I guess I don't understand. Lowering the serving pressure won't cause the CO2 to rush out of solution, it should just pour slower and with less foam (people lower the serving pressure to serve with too short lines; successfully, all the time). If you leave it like that then eventually it will be undercarbed but that takes a while.

 

[wildwest450]

It may not be instantaneous, but the minute you drop the psi, the c02 will start coming out, it has no choice. Why else do 2 liter sodas go flat after a while? It has to have the same pressure on it, as it was carbonated at, or it's coming out. That's why shake and high psi carbonating causes so many problems, there's no way to know at what level the beer is carbed to.

I just bottled for a comp last week. I always turn the pressure almost all the way off, as it's the only way I can fill bottles successfully. From the time it took to cap the bottle and fill the next one, the line was completely full of C02 bubbles. I had to pour 3-4 ozs out to get to good non foamy beer. Once you get your system down there's absolutely no reason to be dispensing at a lower psi that you carb to. It makes no sense. I couldn't imagine having to fiddle with a gauge every time I wanted a beer.

Here's a couple of good articles. I really don't have a way with words.

http://www.micromatic.com/beer-questions/temperature-store-beer-aid-46.html

http://www.micromatic.com/beer-questions/pressure-set-beer-regulator-aid-60.html

They're geared at the bmc industry, so temps are kinda low for homebrewers, but the science still applies.

_

 

[SpanishCastleAle]

I agree that it does come out of solution but it takes days for it to drop the carb level much. For example, I just recently had a slightly overcarbed keg of Mild and I needed to bottle it for the HBT comp, even vented down to ~2psi it just wouldn't 'uncarb' in a reasonable amount of time and I didn't have time to warm it.

FWIW, I cap the bottle as the next one is filling (I don't use or need the stopper). Once I open that picnic tap it pretty much stays open until I'm done. You will get bubbles in the line as you said if you close the tap but pouring at a lower pressure will get you less foamy beer than at a higher pressure, regardless of the carb level. That's why lowering the pressure to bottle works. I agree it's a PITA and no way to run a keezer/kegerator. I only suggested it to the OP just so he could have a beer...and then fix the problem asap. He seemed like he wanted a beer really badly! We've all been there.

 

[mtbiker278]

I've found if you're getting foam coming out you can vent the keg momentarily from the safety valve to reduce the pressure when you pour. The beer isn't going to suddenly out-gas unless you're really overcarbed it. I have a kit that came with 5ft lines and haven't had a problem with foam when venting if needed.

 

[forcabrew]

im having bad foaming in my diy kegerator. it may be that the tower lines are too short, not sure, but there is not much room in the fridge for 10ft of line to each faucet.

 

[DoubleFisted]

With soooo many comments I'm not sure I really know what I am suppose to do about this?

Sent from my iPhone using HB Talk

 

[ultravista]

If force carbing at 12.5 PSI, how long does it take?

 

[Yooper]

If force carbing at 12.5 PSI, how long does it take?

At fridge temperatures, it'll take about 7-10 days.

 

[DoubleFisted]

Well I didn't add hose length just let the co2 bleed out a bit but also only at 2 psi.

Sent from my iPhone using HB Talk

 

[ultravista]

Yooper, is this how you typically carb your kegged beer, 12 PSI for 7 to 10 days (refridgerated) or do you prefer another method?

What would you do with the Dead Guy clone?

 

[SpanishCastleAle]

Well I didn't add hose length just let the co2 bleed out a bit but also only at 2 psi.

If you got that much head pouring at 2 psi then I would say it look like it's pretty overcarbed. It looks nice though, little bit of lacing going on there.

I can't remember where I read it but it allegedly takes 18-21 days for a 'set and forget' keg to reach equilibrium (for a typical carb level and temp). It will be carbed up enough to be good well before that. And I would swear some kegs carb up faster than others but I haven't actually tested it.

 

[Yooper]

Yooper, is this how you typically carb your kegged beer, 12 PSI for 7 to 10 days (refridgerated) or do you prefer another method?

What would you do with the Dead Guy clone?

I do just that- 12 psi in my 40 degree fridge. As SpanishCastleAle said, it's carbed up (drinkable) by then, but it's better in 2-3 weeks.

 

[DoubleFisted]

If you got that much head pouring at 2 psi then I would say it look like it's pretty overcarbed. It looks nice though, little bit of lacing going on there.

I can't remember where I read it but it allegedly takes 18-21 days for a 'set and forget' keg to reach equilibrium (for a typical carb level and temp). It will be carbed up enough to be good well before that. And I would swear some kegs carb up faster than others but I haven't actually tested it.

I am not familiar with the term lacing?

Sent from my iPhone using HB Talk

 

[SpanishCastleAle]

Lacing refers to the foam that sticks to the sides of the glass.

 

[Bobby_M]

I don't think it was ever determined if the original poster actually used 3/16" INSIDE DIAMETER tubing when he replaced his lines. If it's 1/4", that's the problem.

 

[DoubleFisted]

I believe it's quarter inch. Doesn't say I'll go to the hardware store now and replace it. Thanks Bobby

Sent from my iPhone using HB Talk

 

[bruin_ale]

oh damn, good call Bobby.. 1/4" line has waaaay less restriction than 3/16". I think you need about 20-25ft of 1/4" line to balance a system. To give you an idea, 1/4 lines are commonly used in bars where the kegs are stored in a separate room.

 

[DoubleFisted]

Yeah I believe it is probably 1/4" line because I had a guy that works at pepsi give me some of his supply line. Just waiting to get off work so I can replace the hose yet again, and have some delicious beer for the holiday.

 

[SpanishCastleAle]

Good call by Bobby. Several people specified 3/16" but we never verified what you were actually using.

When you cut the new line, go long imo. You can always 'make' foam and you can always cut it shorter. Harder to 'unmake' foam or extend a line.

 

[Flomaster]

here is the handy dandy CO2 carbing chart.

http://www.kegerators.com/carbonation-table.php

I keep my keg at 38 °F so if I wanted to have 2.5 I'd put my psi to 11.25 or there abouts

in theory if I have my beer at 38 °F and psi at 11ish line length should only be controlling the speed of my pour. am I correct in this thinking?

-=Jason=-