Thanks.
Well I've learned a few things. For one, in brewing, I had been using too little coffee to water, and my extraction time was too long. With a bit of experimentation, I think I've found the ideal ratio and volume to brew such that my pot extracts at four minutes, but no longer. This improved the flavor immediately, even with slightly stale coffee.
I've also learned that my recurring Peet's order of two pounds every 25 days (which kept me in constant supply using the low coffee to water brewing I'd been doing) means that about half the time I'm drinking coffee that's stale!
I have adjusted my order and now I'll get one pound at a time, with 2 day shipping. With the proper brewing ratio, I should be getting one pot a day for a week before going through that one pound, possibly with some extra coffee - time will tell. Regardless, I'll be inside the fifteen day window (though I read on sweet Maria's that it's best between 4-24 hours after roasting?? I think I'll let my palate be my guide).
The shipping costs will be higher than I had been paying ($7/week = $365/ year). Enough so that I could justify buying a drum roaster. The Behmor style would pay for itself in about a year, in shipping savings, the Gene in less than two years, and the HotTop in three to four years, assuming that they are reliable enough for twice weekly half pound roasts for that period of time. Peet's pays half the shipping costs I'll mention, which turns out to in most cases to be more money than the actual coffee itself costs.
For now, I think that I will see how much I am able to appreciate the fresher coffee and brewing practice improves the taste and flavor of my coffee, and tinker with the popcorn roaster and the green beans a while longer. If I'm blown away with the fresher roast, either with the popper, or more likely what I'm buying through Peet's, I may not wait too long to buy a roaster and reap the shipping savings and green bean vs roasted bean costs. I suppose there is a learning curve as in all things- that's where you guys fit in!!
TD