Mashed in need hop substitute!!

[nathan33]

So I am mashed in doing an abner clone after just tasting it recently.....****....no Chinook hops....whirlpool and dryhop additions.....what can I substitute to get close......

 

[WayFrae]

You don't have any hops at all?

 

[nathan33]

Ya lots but was going for a clone. Chinook I can have for dryhop but need recommendations for the chinook that whirlpool for 30 min

 

[nathan33]

I have northern brewer summit all the no hops citra amirillo columbus ect.....just trying to get close to chinook on whirlpool addition to get close to abner.

 

[nathan33]

Lots of hops man. Just thought I had some chinook left and want to get as close as possible

 

[nathan33]

Here is recipe.
15# 2 row
.75 caramel 20
.5 corn sugar
Zeus liquid hops for bittering
.75 columbus 30 min
2 oz simcoe whirlpool 30
2 oz centennial whirlpool 30
1 oz chinook. Whirlpool 30
3 oz Simcoe do
2 oz chinook do

The 1 oz chinook whirlpool needs replacement

 

[Aa760]

I vote Amarillo
Not a Chinook sub but I have used it in many styles and can see it working in an amber for a late addition, fwiw!

 

[nathan33]

Abner clone from hf. But amirillo may be what I throw in

 

[jbaysurfer]

Columbus, Northern Brewer of the ones you listed. Nugget works too...I'd use that if I had all 3 of these.

Don't forget to recalculate your IBUs......

Edit: I do like Amarillo, but I don't know if I'd use it with those other hops tbh. Personal preference thing, but Amarillo and Columbus don't play all that well IMHO.

 

[nathan33]

cool I have Columbus and northern brewer. I can throw them in and get Chinook for dry hops