Homebrew Club Loses all My Entries

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

hedonist91

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2009
Messages
71
Reaction score
4
Location
Poughkeepsie, NY
I don't even have the heart to write the whole story, but the short of it is...

I had twelve entries to a competition, two hours from my home, that I dropped off to Defiant Brewing an hour and a half from my home a week earlier. Someone from the Homebrew club picked up my entries from Defiant, and brought them to Chelsea Brewing in Manhattan about 5 days later. Unfortunately, there was a blizzard in Manhattan that day. Chelsea brewing closed earlier than usual because of the snow.

Whoever was responsible for the safe, secure delivery of the entries decided the best thing to do was leave a case of beer (plus a six pack with another competitor's three entries) unattended in front of a closed brewpub in Manhattan, instead of - oh, I don't know - calling someone, or arranging to have them entered and dropped off later when someone could put them behind closed doors.

Instead of calling your humble narrator (the entry form was online, and there were only two competitors' beers missing), as my phone number was entered for each of my twelve entries, I was pulled aside while the winners were being announced by a fellow that was a judge for the day, that I had bs-ed with at the bar in the afternoon. This fellow put the pieces together and realized that it was my beer that had never been tasted, and was left out for a night with no one watching it, in the middle of the city that never sleeps.

Imagine my dismay. Furthermore, we had contacted members of the homebrew club and also employees of Chelsea Brewing to find out what time would be appropriate to show up to make sure we were present for the announcements. We were basically given a shrug in response to all of our queries, so we arrived around 2pm, because apparently no one knew jack. Not that I forced down five hours of good brew or anything, but wow. Wow. No one knows even ballpark, when things are going on. Wow.

After their hippy-like trust that a case of beer won't grow legs and walk off unattended when left out in plain air, I don't find it hard to believe that they wouldn't have the slightest inkling as to what week they would even be done sipping.

Very, very disheartening.
 
In a more positive light, the hobos may have had the best beer of thier miserable lives.

Sux man - my heart goes to ya.
 
Did they offer any recourse? Did you have to pay to post your entries? And do they know who in the hell was so dumb as to leave "free" beer out for the taking?

Tim
 
That really sucks, man.

Would the organizers consider allowing you to to submit additional samples for judging (even if not for competition sake, but just for judging feedback)?

Also, I see you're from Po-Town. I grew-up in Rhinebeck. Cheers!
 
If this was a BJCP sanctioned event you could contact the regional representative and relay your experience. For New York, it would be [email protected]. It doesn't seem like any effort was made by the club to alert you to the loss or compensate you for any entry fees lost.

-chuck
 
Hey all, thanks for reply.

I they got my drinks for the day, my parking which was 40 bucks, apologized like mad gave me a sack of Rahr malt, and even after all that said they want to make it up to me. I kind of caused a scene, which I didn't need to do.

So yeah, it wasn't like they just gave me the middle finger after the whole thing. It was a mistake, probably made by one guy who just wanted to get the job done, regardless of the consequences. It's not the club's fault as a whole, and they did go out of their way to make it up to me.

I just gotta let it go, they're a good bunch of people, it's not everyone's fault, and it's just beer.
 
. . . . I just gotta let it go, they're a good bunch of people, it's not everyone's fault, and it's just beer.

That's the attitude to have, it could be worst. I decided a long time ago that if I'm trusting my entries with someone else, they could be lost. Sounds like they are trying to do right though, but it still sucks.

Brew on my friend:mug:
 
I kind of caused a scene, which I didn't need to do.

I probably would have been escorted off premises...so I understand about that. I think you were in every right to cause a scene.

Anyways. I am sad to hear about the whole thing. It may give you some pleasure to know that the thieves were probably not smart enough to NOT drink straight from the bottle. So they ended up consuming a bunch of yeast and shat themselves...at least one can hope.

I hope you win the next comp!

:mug:
 
You gave enough info... I had an issue with them last year. Got some really stupid, full of attitude responses from the 'dear leader' via email that made me want to smack him in the mouth. I didn't enter this year because of that. My friend actually won 2nd place BOS this year and likes those guys so, to each his own.
 
Back
Top