Slightly low final gravity

Hello. So I brewed my first all grain batch. It was an American pale ale.

My original gravity was 1.060 which was just about spot on assuming I measured it correctly.

My final gravity was definitely low. Around 1.009 when it should have been 1.013. Any reason for concern? Ideas on what could have happened ? What are the implications? Just stronger beer ?

I bottled it last night and seems to taste fine.

Thanks

"should have been 1.013" according to what? Lots of variables could have affected this, e.g. mash temperature, very slight infections etc. This might help: http://byo.com/bock/item/760-hit-your-target-gravity.

According to my brewing classic styles book it should have been 1.013. But I think that would assume 70% efficiency. Also when I plug the numbers into beersmith 1.013 was my estimated fg. I am just curious what might cause a low number.

Too many details have been left out to give you an accurate answer.

1. Efficiency does not play a role in FG, it only affects your OG.
2. What was your mash temperature?
3. What yeast did you use?

As far as the effects of the lower FG, yes your ABV is slightly higher than expected and the beer may also be a bit thinner.

Sounds like a win in my book. Keg it, carb it, drink it.

Mash temp was 152 and I used white labs California ale yeast .

WLP001 *always* over attenuates for me when I make a starter. My last pale shoulda ended up at 1.012 with 80% attenuation (White labs upper limit for cali ale) and I got down to 1.005 (more like 91%)

Your beer will be a little more dry but it'll be fine. Package it up and enjoy!

Thanks !

Next stupid question. When final gravity is taken. It should be done from the fermenter prior to adding priming sugar ?

Lunkerking said:

Thanks !

Next stupid question. When final gravity is taken. It should be done from the fermenter prior to adding priming sugar ?

Click to expand...

Yes. If you add sugar and then check it you will be reading the sugar in suspension also. Is it enough to change it? Probably not but a little math could tell you for sure.

Cheers
Jay

Jaybird said:

Yes. If you add sugar and then check it you will be reading the sugar in suspension also. Is it enough to change it? Probably not but a little math could tell you for sure.

Cheers
Jay

Click to expand...

4 oz of table sugar will give you:
Brew on

doug293cz said:

4 oz of table sugar will give you:

(4 oz / 16 oz/lb ) * 46 ppg / 5 gal = 2.3 points or 0.0023 increased SG​

Brew on

Click to expand...

See... I knew it could be done with math!

Cheers
Jay