Is there such a thing as Over-Sparging?

Hi! First post, and this looks like a GREAT forum. Tons of helpful people, and tons of traffic. I did a quick search, and I apologize if this has been covered someplace and I missed it.

I've been brewing kits (Malt Extract with 1-2lbs. dry grain), and doing a full volume 5-gallon boil. I have a question....

Lately I've been following the Kit directions for the Mash, and when it comes to sparging, I've been heating to the proper temp the entire volume of water that I'm going to use for the boil, and sparging with the full amount. The theory, I guess, is to extract as much of the goodies from the grain as possible.

Is there such a thing as over-sparging? I notice that most kits and recipes call for only about gallons to run through the grain. Is there a reason for this? What harm could I be doing to the quality of the finished product?

(Of course, the directions on the kits are pretty much for a partial boil, which is one of the reasons why I've made up my own rules).

Thanks in advance!

Mikes65, I don't think you're going to do any harm per-se, but sparging a couple of pounds of adjunct grains with your full five gallons may be overkill and time consuming. Just watch your temperature... you don't want tannins from your husks.

I've not done a partial mash in twenty years... so others may have better things to say.

And cheers, and welcome! This is indeed a great forum. -p

I am far from experienced with this, but from what I have read, if you do sparge too much you do risk getting to many tannins in your beer from the grain husks. I suspect, though, that most of us lack the patience to sparge long enough to get to the point where this becomes a problem.

Doing AG or partial mashes, you can over-sparge If you are not buffering the sparge water, you'll start extracting tannins.

When steeping grains water volume doesn't matter much. The volume of grain is small enough that any tannins you might get won't hurt. Realistically, sparging more than 2-3 quarts per pound won't extract anything useful.

David speaks from experience of years of brewing. He speaks the truth.

david_42 said:

Doing AG or partial mashes, you can over-sparge If you are not buffering the sparge water, you'll start extracting tannins.

Click to expand...

by "buffering the sparge water" do you mean adding the correct amount of gypsum....or are you talking about something else that i dont know about (but would like to know)

Hey Mike, if you are mashing, sparging, and doing a full boil, why not try an All Grain trip?

yeah, I'm sure I will at some point. This is my 2nd batch, with a few more on deck. Got the Corney Keg setup (as I dove right into the hobby).

I'm sure that once I gain a little more confidence with all of the procedures, I'll switch to all-grain.

Thanks for the tips!

Yeast Infection said:

by "buffering the sparge water" do you mean adding the correct amount of gypsum....or are you talking about something else that i dont know about (but would like to know)

Click to expand...

Buffering means that the mash PH gets to a certain level where you don't extract tannins from the mashed grain after most of the sugars have been washed out of the mash. If you are batch sparging, then buffering the sparge water isn't nesessary. But you still shouldn't use too much water.

If you extract tannis out of the grain can you taste it right after you boil and take your OG reading?