Crisp is the malting company from the UK. They still practice traditional floor malting of barley for Maris Otter malt. I do not think floor malting is used for Pale Ale malt, but I may be wrong on that.
For brewing purposes, Maris Otter has more color (3 - 4 degrees Lovibond) compared to pale malt (2.5 - 3.5 degrees Lovibond). Maris Otter also has a maximum moisture content of 2.8% compared to Pale Ale malt's maximum of 3% moisture which can result in a higher potential gravity at larger volumes when using Maris Otter (not really applicable for homebrew scale).
Maris Otter is the variety of barley. It is an agriculturally lower yielding variety, which is reflected by the higher price. Pale Ale malt is made from multiple varieties of barley (Brewers Supply Group website lists Optic and Fanfare as recent examples).
Ultimately, the biggest difference will be flavor and mouthfeel.