I ended up finding out that the guy that used to be the brewmaster at Pizza Port, Kirk McHale, had sold or partnered with Humbolt. They still brew and sell the recipe as Humbolt Hemp Ale, it is a bit darker, but tastes almost the same. He also sells a kit called Marry Wanna Beer, which has the lighter crystal malts and seems to be more what I am looking for.
Last night I went to the Port and was talking to the bartender, he was telling me it really is more of an English style ale.
Here is the Marry Wanna Beer recipe (all grain):
OG 1.060
FG 1.012
IBU: 35
SRM: 15 (deep amber)
5.5gal batch (7.3g boil)
12# British Pale Malt
1# Crystal 60L
8oz Crystal 135L
0.75oz Eroica @ 60min
0.75oz Columbus @ 1min
White Labs Dry English Ale
Mash at 155. My efficiency is low, 65%, so take that into account. Also, I see Galena is the substitute for Eroica these days.
Hopville . "Mary Wanna Beer" American Pale Ale Recipe