I am a little less scientific in this area, but I think over pitching is much less of a concern than under pitching. I'm sure in almost all cases I am closer to over pitching than under. Its true you can approximate slurry volume, but how much of that slurry is trub, how many are active yeast cells, how many are dead yeast cells? I have no idea, so I just try to keep it simple.
- Ahead of time I sanitize 0.5 or 1 qt Mason jars. 2 jars per beer batch. Add filtered water to half full mark, boil in microwave, loosely cover, and place in fridge until cold
- Sanitize a 1 cup measuring cup
- For 1.050 and below brews, I take 1 cup of slurry from the top of yeast/trub in primary. For 1.050-1.080 I take 2 cups of slurry. For 1.080+ I will take anywhere between half and 2/3 of the yeast/trub cake depending on beer size.
- Add this to sanitized jars, swirl, and set timer for 15 minutes.
- Pour off top of mason jar into second mason jar until it is either filled, or starts to get to the clumpy trub layer I want to discard.
- Place 2nd jar into fridge. I keep these for up to 4 weeks (direct pitch within 4 weeks), after which I would require a starter prior to pitching. I always decant most of the liquid on top prior to pitching.