I agree with said,pumkinhead,i thought it was more like a soda-and the worst pumpkin beer ive tried,and ironically i thought smashed was probably the best or one of the best ive been able to try but there was some good ones i wasnt able to try due to unavailability,that i would have liked to try.I just finished up drinking my first all-grain pumpkin i made last spring/summer,pretty good and very good aroma.Not as tastey as the smashed but maybe better in aroma.Maybe not but probably just differnet.