First off these weren't real street races, just two idiots flooring it on the back roads, but you got me thinking so I called him and asked. It was a 99 C5, but my friend reminded me of some caviats in which he said I should mention. I still like to remember the glory of blowing his car out of the water with a car I spent $50 on and fixed myself, so let me have my delusions.
First he bought the car used and it had an automatic transmission

and second he claims the street we used to race wasn't a full quarter mile if you figure in time to stop, he claims that he would have caught up to me given some extra road.
The thing about the eagle you have to remember is that it is extremely light and that with the AWD you would take off of the line like a shot.