Holy crap my cider tastes good. I ended up going with the S-04 since it seemed to get good reviews in that crazy juice, yeast, sugar experiment thread, and I wanted to go with a dry yeast. My cider's been fermenting a little over 2 months now and finally is down to a few tiny bubbles rising. I want to bottle it soon but might give it another week. I was curious about how it tastes since this is my 4th batch of cider and I did things a bit differently this time. I took about an ounce out and it is amazing. My recipe this time around:
2 gallons Kirkland Apple juice (not from concentrate)
1 gallon pasturized Gala apple cider (from Walmart, with preservatives)
1.5 lbs brown sugar
3 cups caramel syrup (homemade stuff similar to dark candi syrup)
spices (I think like 8 cloves, 8 alspice berries, couple cinnamon sticks)
3 t yeast nutrient
3 campden tablets
S-04 yeast
I heated about half a gallon of juice with the spices for 30 min, let it cool with the spices in there, and then removed them and added the juice and the rest of the ingredients. OG was 1.070. It foamed up a bit the first day and then went to the slower sparkling wine type bubbling. It's been sitting and bubbling for 10 weeks. SG is 1.014 right now.
The taste is slightly sweet, appley, with a slight spice characteristic that reminds me of a Belgian style beer. The mouthfeel is smooth and wine-like. It actually reminds me of a Riesling. I usually bottle carb my cider but this is so awesome I might bottle some still. My previous ciders (using Nottingham) all had a slight funky flavor and 2 had too much spice that turned into some unpleasant flavor. Main difference between this one and my last 2 batches is the yeast and less spice exposure. I'm anxious now to start drinking this. I guess I'll be taking readings the next few days to see if this is still fermenting or if the bubbles are just CO2 still hanging around. Should I expect the S-04 to take it all the way dry?