I love their cream ale and carabou slobber. I'm about to order a few kits since they have a 15% off kit sale through facebook, I have no idea what I want to brew next!
I really like Surly Furious (IPA) and I liked the Irish draught kit. I sampled a neighbors "Speckled Heifer" and I really liked that but I didn't brew that one myself.
I'll know more in about a month. Their Caribou slobber was good, I'm bottling a Phat Tyre tomorrow, and will be brewing their midnight porter tomorrow as well, with the AK47 pale mild to follow.