I use our bread machine fairly often (Well, it tends to get used in streaks) and I like it. There isn't much cleanup to it, since I just pour ingredients into it and turn it on. The clean-up is *maybe* wiping the non-stick pan with a paper towel every few loaves.
The bread is very different from the homemade ones I've made in the dutch oven. To be honest, a bread machine's bread is best eaten right away. For some reason the texture seems to degrade quickly in my opinion. Bread made in the dutch oven, Artisan style, seems to keep a better texture for longer.
I guess what I say is that the two loaves are not really comparable, but it's awesome to be able to come home at lunch, throw a few things in the machine, and press a button and then when you get home have hot fresh bread waiting. Same thing for mixing it up right after work and it's ready for dinner.
I've seen a TON of bread machines at yard sales over the past several years. Cuisinart is a high priced brand, and as far as I know should be well built.