Update -
It's been two weeks since I started this thing. Six days ago it was at 1.032. Now it's at 1.029, it's a gorgeous burnt orange color, and it tastes like home made pumpkin pie - absolutely fantastic, better than I could have hoped for. That said, I think I screwed up somewhere.
I'm thinking...
- I read my OG incorrectly (used a refractometer instead of a hydrometer)
- It simply hasn't finished fermenting
- OG was right, it's done fermenting, but it didn't attenuate completely
I went ahead and racked it over to secondary tonight to get it off all that trub. I'm gonna let it sit for a week and check the gravity again. If it's holding at 1.029 I'll go ahead and bottle it. Like I said, it tastes amazing, so worst case scenario is I have an extremely sessionable 3.5% pumpkin ale.
I'll keep you posted.