• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

NHC 2012 First Round Scoresheets

Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I drank mine.

I certainly wouldn't do that yet. My case last year:

In 2011 I entered 12 beers to the Seattle judging center. When I got the scoresheets back 11 had empty 'place awarded boxes'. 1 beer had a '3' in the place awarded box on the coversheet.

After a week or two when I actually got my placements from the AHA, 3 out of the 12 received a placement to go to the second round. The ironic part is that the beer that had a '3' in the place awarded box on the coversheet ended up not placing. This was telling enough for me to not trust the cover sheets.
 
REGARDING PLACE INDICATORS ON SCORE SHEETS (Sorry if that looks all shout-y and authoritarian, just wanted to make sure everyone saw it!):

Our judges were told to go ahead and put a place indicator on the cover sheet if that beer advanced in their flight (though even some of them were unaware that this was OK), and MOST did. I say most, because there were some flights where this didn't get done, and I take full responsibility for it. In their zeal to get scoresheets stapled, sorted, and stuffed (which I told them was their primary goal at the end of the day, so that attendees could pick them up then) or because they were concerned that sheets would get lost in the confusion, some stewards removed the scoresheets from the table before mini-BOS had completed, and those sheets MAY not have been noted as finishing in an advancing position.

Most, though, did indicate whether a beer was advancing - and next year they all will (it's at the top of my after-action report). To be on the safe side, hang onto a little bit of any beer that scored over 30 (the minimum to advance) - you can drink them in commiseration if there's no happy surprises on 4 May.

Thanks, all, and best of luck.

Prost,
Josh Weikert
Stoney Creek Homebrewers
Organizer - NHC 1st Round (Philadelphia)
 
I wonder how Pittsburgh judging went this weekend. I would be lying if I didn't say that I'm slightly anxious to see how I did on my saison. Plus I want to see what they say about my pedio rope in the dubbel for purely entertainment purposes. It hurt me to find out I had sent a beer that developed the rope and almost thought to contact the event organizer to have them pull the beer. I've helped judge a comp in the past and it seemed people intentionally sent bad beer to find out what was the matter with it, which is weird to me. So I'm actually sort of embarrassed because I'm THAT guy this time.
 
I wonder how Pittsburgh judging went this weekend. I would be lying if I didn't say that I'm slightly anxious to see how I did on my saison. Plus I want to see what they say about my pedio rope in the dubbel for purely entertainment purposes. It hurt me to find out I had sent a beer that developed the rope and almost thought to contact the event organizer to have them pull the beer. I've helped judge a comp in the past and it seemed people intentionally sent bad beer to find out what was the matter with it, which is weird to me. So I'm actually sort of embarrassed because I'm THAT guy this time.

Good luck! I'm hoping we get our sheets from Pittsburgh quickly. I don't mind the wait before judging, but once the scores exist I want to know what they are. I have decent confidence with the beers I sent, but there is always a hit or miss nature to competitions, especially when you enter sour beers in every category that allows them…
 
I received mine via email from San Diego today.

My Scottish 80 was noted on the cover sheet as 2nd place and checked "advanced to mini BOS".

Scored 39.
 
Minny scores are out. Got a 35 for a bourbon barrel flanders red in specialty category. Mini-bos was marked but no place indicated.
 
Mine too. Judging started last night and continues through Saturday. 535 entries from what I heard. How many did you send? Man these guys scoring 40+ and not getting a sniff of the second round is tough.

I sent in a Schwarzbier and a Porter.. neither placed.

Congrats Osagedr on your silver and two bronze and good luck with your entry into the second round. :mug:
 
Anyone heard anything from Pittsburgh? The website just says "database received", not sure what that means...
 
I had checked that last night and I was wondering the same thing. We're only 9 days away from the official release of all results. So if we find out earlier than 04May then my guess is it will not be much earlier at this rate.
 
I sent in a Schwarzbier and a Porter.. neither placed.

Congrats Osagedr on your silver and two bronze and good luck with your entry into the second round. :mug:

How do you know you didn't place? From what I have read, it seems like putting a place on the sheets sent out is the exception and not the rule. The NHC website makes me think that places will not be announce until May 4.
 
I sent in a Schwarzbier and a Porter.. neither placed.

Congrats Osagedr on your silver and two bronze and good luck with your entry into the second round. :mug:

Thanks man. Very happy to have three second-round entries. They are all nice beers but to be honest not the ones I was expecting to do well!

Are you sending anything to Montreal? Mine will go in the mail on Monday--likely about a dozen entries. May is ridiculously busy for competitions.
 
I had checked that last night and I was wondering the same thing. We're only 9 days away from the official release of all results. So if we find out earlier than 04May then my guess is it will not be much earlier at this rate.

I heard that Pittsburgh had two leftover categories from the first weekend. Hopefully they got most of the sheets ready to go last week, and they got them in the mail Monday. Hopefully we'll start seeing them today or tomorrow?
 
Anyone have any insight as to what's going on with Chi-town? They seem to be the only site left still judging.
 
I entered one beer this year. Got a 41 for my Imperial Rye IPA, entered into the specialty category. Mini bos was checked but no placing...
 
I just received my score sheet from St.Paul. I scored a 42.5 for my Foreign Extra Stout. The mini bos box was checked but no placement indicated so I guess we just have to wait till its posted online to know for sure.
 
I got my scores from Indy 3 days ago. Scored 38 for my pale ale and made the mini-BOS, but no placement noted. Really satisfying for me.
 
Anyone enter Atlanta? I can't remember when it said judging would take place but it says, "Database Received." I haven't received anything via snail mail or e-mail yet for any of my 5 entries.
 
I entered Atlanta. Apparently judging took place April 21-22. I haven't received any scoresheets yet either, I've lowered myself to just checking the NHC website 3 times a day.
 
Back
Top