Looks like the two magnets I purchased aren't strong enough. The stir rod sits and vibrates on both speeds. Some times it flops around a bit, but no spin. I can't move the fan any closer to the cover, it's almost touching them already. I may try them closer together before buying more/stronger ones. Good thing I used glue & and not epoxy!
Maybe the rpms are too high? I tore open an old 4GB drive for the magnets. They are fairly heavy, but much stronger than the ones I purchased. In fact, set face to face, I can't separate them with my bare hands. Made the mistake of getting a pinky in between them, ouch!
Edit
Well, as Murphy Rules, the new magnets are enough thinner that I'll have to get longer screws for the fan. There's about a 1/8" gap between the magnets and the cover. It was 1/4" and by running the nuts out to the very end, I'm getting a little action, but not enough. If I take the cover off and hold the flask just a hair above the magnets, it works! Off to the store.
Tonight is the Heart of the Valley meeting, I'll just go a little early and hit a hardware store. Since the meeting is at the good LHBS, I'll get a London ale yeast for the Schwartz bier - Porter experiment.