• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

Mistake #1

Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

jbf101

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2013
Messages
49
Reaction score
5
Howdy all.

I brewed a porter from a kit (Homebrew Heaven Scuttlebut Porter, highly recommend this one btw). The entire brew process went smooth, hit OG and FG within .001 points. I mixed up 5 oz of corn sugar (Came with the kit) in some boiled water (Cooled back down to 70 degrees). Put it the bottom of my bottling bucket and racked my beer on top of it.

After racking all the beer into the bucket i realized i had about 4.25 or so gallons instead of the 5 I thought i had (I've since added marks on my carboys so i know how much is actually in them). I will also adopt the practice of racking into my bucket (Which has far more accurate measurement lines) and then using a calculator/scale for the amount of sugar for the style of beer. Hindsight is always 20/20 i suppose.

I later looked in the cup i mixed up the sugar in, and there were deposits lining it, so hopefully that lessened it some....

Anyways, i went ahead with bottling the beer, placed them in cardboard boxes with a towel underneath them. These were kept in my "Man Cave
of sorts in the house, with a temp ranging from 69-72 depending on my wife's mood. This was on 10/7. I put one in the fridge on 10/14 and let it cool down overnight (I'm impatient sue me) so i could enjoy a tasty beer in the morning (I work graveyard, not an alcoholic). It tasted great, and to my surprise, was actually a little under-carbed. I thought the worse was over!

Come today, i walk in, decide to check on my beer, and low and behold, a shattered bottle. I immediately went into crisis mode and started searching the forums for how much pressure 12oz bottles could handle etc etc. Couldn't find anything, decided to move my bottles to the garage (Significantly colder in there, mid 40's to mid 50's) to try and stymie the yeast. I also took one of the bottles popped it open, expecting a gusher or something, and to my surprise, nothing happened. Poured it into a glass and there was a good amount of head, but nothing super insane.

To sum up, i'm confused... I'm hoping the bottle had an infection... or was somehow structurally damaged. The math all points to too much priming sugar, which is totally my bad; learned from my mistake and so on. Anyways i'm just trying to get some advice from more seasoned brewers and/or pass on my mistake so other newbies can learn from it.

Other news though, i brewed up a Honey Orange Cream Ale (Honey Malt, not honey) yesterday that i hope will be tasty. Checked on it this morning and it has a nice krausen layer on top of it, so not all is terrible!
 
5 oz isn't terribly over priming. My two guesses are you either had a weak bottle, or your priming solution wasn't evenly distributed and that one got just a little bit more. Moving them wasn't a bad idea, but it will likely take a bit longer for them to finish carbing especially at that low of a temp. I think all in all you should be ok though. Also, you'll want to refrigerate them for at least 48 hours to make sure the CO2 gets back into solution. Otherwise you could get a nice head, but the beer won't feel carbed.
 
I had a bottle bomb after making a similar mistake. I'd given some away too, but those are all empties now, only one of mine at home blew. I have been meaning to get a scale and improve the way I measure volumes for a while; this was the thing that motivated me to do it so I have no more problems with bottles.

Hopefully you won't have more break.
 
Very reassuring to hear. I usually let them sit in the fridge for a couple days, the one week test was more for flavor than how carbed (it was a concern though) it was. Still new at this and I like to taste the progression of the beer as it conditions.
 
Well now jbf101, If that was your first mistake, you're ahead of the curve on most of us. :D
I agree, sounds like 1 defective bottle. Brew on! :mug:
 
Do you use a bench capper or a wing capper? I just realized that my wing capper has a serious stress riser at the point where it "grips" the neck of the bottle. I actually chipped at least one bottle the last time I bottled a batch. Switching to a bench capper ASAP.
 
Well, first noticeable mistake anyway. I'm fairly meticulous with my cleaning and sanitation. Built a fermentation chamber in my garage so i could control my temps and all that.

I use a wing capper for the time being. Bench is in my want list though.
 
Back
Top