This thread is approaching the length where it takes longer to read through it than it does to fully ferment a batch of Apfelwein!!
I started my first batch shortly after reading the first few pages of this thread on 8/23/2008. 3,853 posts later (I've read every one), it's 9/17/2008, so that batch is almost finished in the primary!
First batch was 5 gallons + Lalvin K1-V1116 because LHBS was out of Montrachet. Since then I've found some Montrachet at a different store.
Second batch was started a week later, 8/30/2008. Since everyone on this thread was saying it gets better with age, I figured
why wait a whole two weeks? Experimented by using Weihenstephan Weizen yeast (
Wyeast #3068). The website isn't kidding when they say "This strain is a true top cropping yeast requiring full fermenter headspace of 33%." Within 48 hours my brew made it up into airlock. I had to siphon a bit out to give it more room. It continued to have crazy amounts of krausen but it never reached the airlock again, though it did come quite close!
Fermentation temperatures have been in the low 70s on average. My first batch (OG 1.059) is getting clearer by the day. Since this weekend will be 4 weeks, I'll take a measurement and perhaps be ready to bottle!
Based on all the feedback in this thread, I'd like to leave it longer in the primary since I hear there is tremendous improvement over time. However, that's what the second batch is for, right? My desire to let the first batch sit is easily outweighed by my desire to drink it with SWMBO.
If it is as good as everyone here says it will be, my first order of business after bottling will be to clean out that primary and start a new batch. I like the three-dedicated-carboys approach. Perhaps if this first batch turns out well I'll get a third 5-gallon BB and try an original batch now that I have Montrachet.
... and yes, I added my gallon contributions to
the total gallons of Apfelwein thread.