Rivenin
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2010
- Messages
- 3,258
- Reaction score
- 342
That's the one I'm ordering.. Wasn't sure if DC input was right..
yep, DC would be correct, most if not all PIDS in this spectrum only sent out DC signal.
That's the one I'm ordering.. Wasn't sure if DC input was right..
the second one down is similar to what you describe
https://www.homebrewtalk.com/showthread.php?t=382286
Actually thats not going to work. I need 1 PID that can run both elements at the same time since both will be inside the same vessle. That one will only allow power to one element at a time. thanks though.
Question on pid control. I am using a design similar to the 30 a single element pid and when the pid is showing no power out, I am still getting power to the element. I have also checked this with a voltage meter and it reads 240. Any suggestions on what is causing this? Have gained a lot of knowledge from this forum, just can't figure this one out. Any help would be appreciated. 
It is normal for a solid state relay output to have voltage even when "off". However, no current should be flowing (if it is, your relay is defective). Is your element heating up?
I was looking for a drawing similar to Kal's electric brewery but I couldn't find one. A couple were close, so I took 3 different PT drawings and mashed them together.
I was going to include an alarm switch in the mash PID, but did'nt have room. I'm pretty sure it's correct, but this is where I add legal ease fine print.
Edit: I updated drawing to include four alarm switches
I know this has been covered ad-nauseam in multiple threads, but I will again state (as would any engineer running a UL certified panel shop) that implementing an e-stop by shorting a HOT line to ground (through a resistor to limit current or not) in the way that's been here is not a safe way to do it.This looks very similar to what I will be doing. Has anyone vetted or used this diagram?
I know this has been covered ad-nauseam in multiple threads, but I will again state (as would any engineer running a UL certified panel shop) that implementing an e-stop by shorting a HOT line to ground (through a resistor to limit current or not) in the way that's been here is not a safe.
If you do want an e-stop, spend the extra $20 and have the e-stop switch disengage the two HOT lines through a contactor or relay. Use a normally open contactor and the e-stop switch hold the contactor closed while it's pulled out. That's safe.
Kal
I'm not a UL code expert but some things come to mind (just going with a common sense approach): You shouldn't purposely shunt current to ground. Ground's there for safety, not for functional use. It also won't work right if the upstream breaker isn't GFI. Building equipment (like a panel like this) that makes the assumption that it has to be GFI projected to work right isn't good. Next time I talk to a UL shop I'll ask for the specifics...i've been thinking about this quite a bit and have yet to come up with a 'smoking gun' that the gfci e-stop method is a code violation or a use of equipment outside of its listing. i'm in the camp of using a contactor instead of a gfci trip but i can't find a fault (ha ha) in the gfci e-stop method, other than my own prejudices.
I'm not a UL code expert but some things come to mind (just going with a common sense approach): You shouldn't purposely shunt current to ground. Ground's there for safety, not for functional use. It also won't work right if the upstream breaker isn't GFI. Building equipment (like a panel like this) that makes the assumption that it has to be GFI projected to work right isn't good. Next time I talk to a UL shop I'll ask for the specifics...
Kal
and that's my hangup, the idea of 'purposely' introducing one hazard to mitigate another hazard. it doesn't make sense and in the industrial world there are other means to accomplish the same thing but i can't for the life of me can't find a code section which prohibits the gfci e-stop approach.
I know this has been covered ad-nauseam in multiple threads, but I will again state (as would any engineer running a UL certified panel shop) that implementing an e-stop by shorting a HOT line to ground (through a resistor to limit current or not) in the way that's been here is not a safe way to do it.
If you do want an e-stop, spend the extra $20 and have the e-stop switch disengage the two HOT lines through a contactor or relay. Use a normally open contactor and the e-stop switch hold the contactor closed while it's pulled out. That's safe.
Kal
I go in the other direction: I don't think an e-stop's needed on a panel to begin with (otherwise I would have installed one). I think an on/off switch is fine. I keyed my on/off switch for added safety but it's not required. Depends on the location/situation.I prefer this method for the E-Stop and like the fact that it is a separate way to shut it off if needed other than relying on the breaker. One question, would you use the e-stop as a master switch or should I still instal a keyed switch?
IMO, the biggest danger is that when the GFCI fails, you have no estop, and you may not know it.
Hello all, I am in process of trying to rebuild my propane brewing system and move it on over to e-brewing... I am horrible with electrical theory, but can read diagrams fairly well... Really what I'd like to make happen is something like Nostalgia's control panel that P-J gave him some suggestions on, with only just a couple subtle differences... Is there anyone out there who can hook a brother up with a nice, easy to follow diagram?
Tell me what you want that's different, and I'll try to put something together for you.
Brew on
Ok, let me make sure I have all the details correct, and ask some additional questions. You want the following:Excellent, thank you very much!
So basically this is what I'd like to build, I have a HERMS coil already plumbed into my HLT, but I'd still like to have the third PID in the center, just for closer monitoring of temps in my Mash tun.
On the backside of this one he has four outlets turned on and off by the four bottom switches on the front panel. I would have two outlets with front switches for my pumps, and then a single 110v/double usb outlet controlled by the third front switch, that way I could use my phone for timer and music while keeping it charged and also run my "El Cheapo" vent hood.
I wouldn't want that big honking red switch on top either, so the fourth front switch would be replaced with a keyed master on/off.
I'd also leave the lighted kill switches for the elements as they are. Does all that make sense?
Ok, let me make sure I have all the details correct, and ask some additional questions. You want the following:
- Two heating elements, one for HLT and one for boil ketlle?
- HLT element power?
- BK element power?
- Do both elements need to be on at same time (for back to back brews)?
- Three PID's, HLT, MLT, BK?
- One for HLT driving SSR for element?
- One for MLT, no SSR, monitoring only?
- One for BK driving SSR for element?
- Key operated main power switch?
- No EPO (emergency power off) switch?
- Two switched 120V pump outlets?
- One switched 120V duplex outlet?
- Safety devices?
- GFCI protection is assumed external to controller.
- Individual circuit breakers for each element (if not you will need to use heavier wiring if both elements need to be on at once)?
- Fuses for PID's, & outlets are assumed. Breakers preferred?
- Any interlocks?
- "Safe start" (main power won't come on unless all other switches off)?,
- Float switches to prevent dry firing the elements?
- "Panel door open" power off?
- Other interlocks?
Does anybody (or P-J, if you're still following this thread ) know what software was used to make these diagrams? Looking back at this thread, I can't find any reference to what software was used. Thanks!
I remember seeing someone say Vizio somewhere... Any Mac users out there know of a good app to do this same thing?
IrieElephant: This sounds nearly identical to my 50A back to back design that many have build. I have pictures and wiring diagrams available here.
Good luck!
Kal
I remember seeing someone say Vizio somewhere... Any Mac users out there know of a good app to do this same thing?
First Doug, please accept my sincerest gratitude for spending time on Christmas trying to help me out, it is very, very much appreciated!
So yes, 2 elements, one in HLT and one in BK. Power switches for each. And preferably the ability to have both firing at the same time for back to back batches.
Three PIDs one controlling an SSR for the HLT element, one specifically for monitoring of MLT temps, not controlling anything, and one controlling an SSR for the BK. 120 VAC case fan for additional cooling of SSRs.
Key operated main power switch, no E-stop, one duplex with individually switched outlets for pumps, one duplex with both outlets powered from a single switch.
No particular safety devices. The system will draw power from a 60 amp GFCI in my Main panel fed to a 60 amp spa panel in the brewery area.
Internal breakers for each element, and internal breakers for 110/120 VAC components. Panel mount fuses for PIDs. No interlocks or other safety devices, just the basics lol
A good diagram of how each component attaches to the next and perhaps suggestions of best parts to go with will get me rocking and rolling! Again, I am incredibly thankful for your help with this.
Ok, this should be close to what you are looking for. For a 60 A service, you'll need to feed it with 4 AWG wire, as 6 AWG is only rated for 55 A. On the load side of the 30 A breakers you can use 10 AWG. The load side of the 10 A breakers can use 16 or 18 AWG. After the 1 A fuses, you can use down to 22 AWG if you want.
View attachment 326197
Let me know if you have any questions.
Enter your email address to join: