Did a post get deleted on page 99?
At the risk of opening a can O' worms, I have to ask this. Is there really a 'moral' difference between rubbing ink off your hand to get back in line, and bringing mules to get extra bottles for yourself? I fail to see what makes one more acceptable than the other. No matter how you look at it, one person is ending up with more than the intended limit of 1 per person.
Please enlighten me, as I'm just trying to understand why muling appears to be considered acceptable by a majority, and the other is "cheating" the system. Why are not both 'cheating' the system?
Obviously it's different if your spouse or whatever likes the beer and drinks it/you both share bottles. Also trading is a separate action as well to me. (I did trade for extra MVB)
Fair devil's advocate question.
I was confused til you clarified that you meant mules with no interest in supporting the brewery. In that case, there may still be some benefit if the mule master buys the mules pizza, or tries to get them to try a beer or wine, etc on site. But if they are just physical bodies who might as well be sleeping during their visit, the difference nearly vanishes. Until you consider
1 per person. If that person doesn't want to be there and pouts in the car the whole time, that person is still a unique visitor in line that day for beer. So it comes down to respecting the system set up by JK.
Same end result, different in terms of following JK's rules.
Increase bottle limits and then it won't give people near the incentive to cheat the system. With a release of this size, 1 per is just silly. It really says a big FU to people not from the area. There is really no incentive to travel that far to get 1 bottle. This is why people mule and hustle. Locals can get 3 bottles for far less cost by coming every day. And sadly some locals point fingers when they are just as guilty.
If you ask, maybe JK will write an apology note to you for not opening near your city.
Srsly? The incentive is going out, trying the beer, and getting the bottle. If 1 is not enough incentive for you, fine. I understand 2 would be more of an incentive, but then MvB would've sold out Saturday afternoon (I think ~1900 sold by EOB on Saturday), and the people planning to come Sunday couldn't have gotten one.
And if the limit was 2pp, people would still mule.
Maybe fewer mules, but I doubt it would lower beyond half as many (including mule master), which is the break even point for the same number of bottles per mule master.
If an awesome brewery opened in DFW or Dallas and I didn't go to releases because it was only 1pp and a long drive, I wouldn't for the slightest moment think that brewery was saying FU to me or other out-of-towners. I'd either hope to try the beer with my Austin tasting group or trade for it so I could share with them.