How to classify a beer

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Pyg

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2014
Messages
2,772
Reaction score
1,340
Location
Halfmoon
I made what my LHBS labeled as a "cream ale"
3.3 gold LME
2 light DME
1 oz cascade (60min)
1/2 oz cascade (15)
1/2 hallertau (5)
Windsor dry British ale yeast

After primary I came to the conclusion this was not a "cream ale" as I know it, since there would be no creaminess or sweetness.
I dry hopped with 1/2 citra.

I know have a 4%abv that has a big citra hop flavor.
What would be the classification?
It is hoppy like an IPA, but low ABV
It is not cream ale because it is too hoppy!
It is light bodied
SWMBo says to just tell people it is "beer".
I do have some friends who know beer and want to give a decent classification.

"A hoppy, light bodied, low ABV ale" ?
 
I try not to get to worried about classifying my beers, im more interested in enjoying the taste of whatever bastard brew i have concocted.

Maybe classify it as a trans atlantic pale ale, as it is pale, its ale, but the hops take it out of the english bitters and the yeast takes it out of american pale ale.
 
I made what my LHBS labeled as a "cream ale"
3.3 gold LME
2 light DME
1 oz cascade (60min)
1/2 oz cascade (15)
1/2 hallertau (5)
Windsor dry British ale yeast

After primary I came to the conclusion this was not a "cream ale" as I know it, since there would be no creaminess or sweetness.
I dry hopped with 1/2 citra.

I know have a 4%abv that has a big citra hop flavor.
What would be the classification?
It is hoppy like an IPA, but low ABV
It is not cream ale because it is too hoppy!
It is light bodied
SWMBo says to just tell people it is "beer".
I do have some friends who know beer and want to give a decent classification.

"A hoppy, light bodied, low ABV ale" ?

It looks like a blonde ale, but it shouldn't really be 'hoppy' with the little bit of hops in the recipe. If it's "IPA hoppy", you must have accidentally doubled or quadrupled the late hops. It looks like it would have very little hops flavor and aroma, and what little is there may be 'clean' hoppiness.

Keep in mind that a cream ale is not the least bit 'creamy'. It's actually light and crisp, almost like a Bud Light in the mouthfeel. There may be a hint of malt flavor which can be perceived as malt sweetness, but no caramel flavor at all.


A cream ale (copied from the BJCP style guidelines):

6A. Cream Ale
Aroma: Faint malt notes. A sweet, corn-like aroma and low levels of DMS are commonly found. Hop aroma low to none. Any variety of hops may be used, but neither hops nor malt dominate. Faint esters may be present in some examples, but are not required. No diacetyl.

Appearance: Pale straw to moderate gold color, although usually on the pale side. Low to medium head with medium to high carbonation. Head retention may be no better than fair due to adjunct use. Brilliant, sparkling clarity.

Flavor: Low to medium-low hop bitterness. Low to moderate maltiness and sweetness, varying with gravity and attenuation. Usually well attenuated. Neither malt nor hops prevail in the taste. A low to moderate corny flavor from corn adjuncts is commonly found, as is some DMS. Finish can vary from somewhat dry to faintly sweet from the corn, malt, and sugar. Faint fruity esters are optional. No diacetyl.

Mouthfeel: Generally light and crisp, although body can reach medium. Smooth mouthfeel with medium to high attenuation; higher attenuation levels can lend a “thirst quenching” finish. High carbonation. Higher gravity examples may exhibit a slight alcohol warmth.

Overall Impression: A clean, well-attenuated, flavorful American lawnmower beer.

Comments: Classic American (i.e., pre-prohibition) Cream Ales were slightly stronger, hoppier (including some dry hopping) and more bitter (25-30+ IBUs). These versions should be entered in the specialty/experimental category. Most commercial examples are in the 1.050–1.053 OG range, and bitterness rarely rises above 20 IBUs.

History: An ale version of the American lager style. Produced by ale brewers to compete with lager brewers in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic States. Originally known as sparkling or present use ales, lager strains were (and sometimes still are) used by some brewers, but were not historically mixed with ale strains. Many examples are kräusened to achieve carbonation. Cold conditioning isn’t traditional, although modern brewers sometimes use it.

Ingredients: American ingredients most commonly used. A grain bill of six-row malt, or a combination of six-row and North American two-row, is common. Adjuncts can include up to 20% flaked maize in the mash, and up to 20% glucose or other sugars in the boil. Soft water preferred. Any variety of hops can be used for bittering and finishing.
 
I agree with @ol-hazza, first classify it as 'good' or 'not as good'.

The only reason I'd be concerned about classifying it is if I were entering it in a contest.

If your friends want to classify it, invite them over for a tasting session and ask them what they think of it. They can actually taste it and give you feedback that way, which is important.
 
@yooper
I had separated out 1 gallon and left it as is. The remaining 4 was dry hopped with 1/2 oz of citra ,
This has given it a very citra hop flavor.
But it is not really hoppy like an ipa.
The only reason I try to classify the beer because it affords me the opportunity to try to educate some friends who just drink "beer".
Being able to explain to people what they are drinking and why it deviates and differs from beers in that class satisfies the beer geek in me!

Thanks for input!
 
Back
Top