Had a mess of a bottle share last night...I'll save you all from the pictures of my 2 oz pours, but:
Arthur Puncheon: Had back to back with a July '15 Arthur for comparison. I'd be lying if I said I recall exactly what blue-label Arthur tasted like but I dug this. Had more tartness, notably on the finish, than base Arthur. Also more oaky and dry...interested to see this develop.
CD19: This was crazy good for me - struck the balance between the threads and barrel. Had that wheaty, dry, tart Florence with the crispness of Arthur. Beautiful nose. One of the better CD's for me.
Elaborative 3: Was wrecked the last time I tried this so glad to get it again. Straight chocolate brownies. Touch of barrel. Just fantastic.
Elaborative 4: I know it's not limited or anything, but like, I love this beer. That is all.
Elaborative 5: This is doing really well - Rooibos is really coming out. I like this beer more and more each time I try it. Would love to dome a bottle of this.
Juicy b3: Good as always, tart, strong barrel, some fruity character. Not my favorite HF wine barrel beer but certainly nothing wrong with it.
M&C 8: Fan-friggin-tastic. Happy to drink this whenever.
Good times all around.