First brew.... I was interested in a prohibition style beer using 2.2 pre hopped Premier malt extract from the market and 4 lbs of sugar dry yeast 5 gallons. This beer had a cidery flavor before bottling and was really not too bad after 21 days conditioning.... But you could tell it waS a boozer and a cheap taste.
Then I tried Mangrove jacks Czech pilsener kit and used brown sugar instead of dextrose... BIG MISTAKE... cidery again. Time healed it (21 days bottle conditioning).
My next batch was a 2.2 premier malt (unhopped this time) with 1 lb dry amber malt and 1 lb dextrose.... 1 oz UK Golding hops. My tastiest brew and did not get cidery.
cleaned up
Now (with guidance from member YOOPER here Im waiting on a Newcaste tastealike in bottles that hopefully will be the best yet.
I have learned 3 important things here.... 1. Dont open the fermentor for at least 10 days for any reason... and... 2. F the secondary... and 3. any newbie fermenting over 69 degrees is bad. The more you fiddle with the brew the more chance of problems. also at least 14 days to bottle condition before even opening one. I was imatient and did none of the above... But after time still had drinkable good tasting beer (not great beer).