I may have had it overxarbed this whole time. Ive been periodically going and purging it while its disconnected from the co2.
I attached the co2 and set it to 10 psi and got foam at first, but the second half came out fine. It was much less carbed than it was earlier when i set it really low and pulled a somewhat descent pint. Ive got it aet to about 11 psi now and im about to go pull another and see how it goes.
When these two kwgs float i will go through and replace all the seals just for peace of mind, but again it seems like it may have just been overcarbed.
As previously stated im brand new to kegging, and though id like to think i have a logical mind, i didnt think to purge it several times to allow whats it the solution to dissipate before setting it back to the proper psi. Lesson learned hopefully. Ill report back later tonight and see how it is in a few pints.