So I'm going to make this as a holiday cider, and the reviews look great.
Where i'm stuck: carbonated or still?
I've only done two ciders, a 8.5% with a bit of brown sugar, and a 6.5% with some malic acid, for a tart/sour cider.
With the 'holiday' flavors in there, I could see it going over better as a still cider, but that has me a little nervous, having never left one still. Do you serve it warm? How do you warm it up? Any danger in re-heating already-alcoholic liquid?
Would the bubbles take away too much from the "holiday-ness" of the cinnamon and caramel?
You'll find people in both camps, but I'm in the one (the best one, of course) that goes with carbonation! I don't know what it is, but I think it adds the right touch.