......I use a Therminator and I have found it's preferable not to allow any hop trub into the unit as it takes forever to get it all out, no matter how much I recirculate PBW through it. Perhaps I'm fanatical about hop matter in my beer but I suspect no more than the next guy.......
I recently found out the same thing. Threw my pellet hops straight into the boil. 1 oz at 60, 1/2 oz at 30, 1/2 oz at 5 for a 5 gallon batch and I spent 2 hours running boiling water, then hot Oxi, then hot water, then Star San thru it and still didn't get every bit out. I wouldn't expect to get it ALL out but it took a while before it was just a tiny bit.
With a plate chiller, arent you leaving your wort hotter, longer, than with an IC?
Yes. However, from some of the more experienced brewers on the board (some of which brewed professionally at one time or now) it does not hurt to let the wort sit that long to do the whirpool and then settle. To me personally seems to contradict what others say about bringing the wort down below a certain temp as soon as possible after flameout.
I did order one as I want to try one out because I have a plate chiller. However, I have my doubts about it (just sayin). I may just end up going back to an IC and chalk this up to $260.00 worth of experience (plate chiller + hop strainer).
The chiller works great, but time wise and work wise and money wise not so much. One pass and your wort is at (or below) pitching temps (I use ice water). BUT then you spend a lot of time flushing it out. When I used a Jamils type WP immersion chiller, I had my wort to 60 degrees in 20 minutes many times. Then I pulled it out of the brew pot, rinsed it with a strong spray of clean water and set it aside. Done.
I do like the fact that once my stand is built I can bolt the plate chiller onto the stand and leave it there. Thats the reason I ended up with it in the first place. I HOPE that I can actually get my new Blichmann pots to whirlpool properly and I will be singing the praises of this setup!!!
I guess, like a lot of other things it boils down to personal preference. I do this to relax and have good beer on hand, not to win any time race. However, I want to make the process as simple and as easy as I can.