I use one of those styrofoam coolers that come from Omaha Steaks. I punched holes in it for the silicone lines in and out of the cooler so I can leave the lid on. I only put a gallon or so of water in the bottom (3 inches) or just enough to cover the submersible fountain pump I bought from Lowes. Two, two liter jugs of ice will last 24 hours when I'm lagering in the low to mid-50's, but I insulate my fermenter well with a blanket. My blanket may be much better than the Anvil insultation as that doesn't even cover the top of the fermenter. Again, I'm not using the Anvil system (using the cooler from
www.ballandkeg.com) so maybe my fountain pump is better, not sure. Mine is rated at 80 GPH flow. Also, my water in the cooler is right around 32 to 34 F once I have it running so I don't understand why folks are having issues getting the cooling water down to close to freezing temps. Maybe my cheap ass styrofoam cooler is better and the small amount of water I use is easier to cool down.