Thanks for the tips guys. I'm making a list of the different suggestions.
I have been using the White Labs vials to make a yeast starter in flask so no dirty scissors are involved. ha I soak the flask in starsan before putting anything in it.
The measuring cup I use is plastic. I don't pour back in. I do not spray the outside of the bucket though.
One thing I did think about that I use a stainless steel spoon for stirring during boil and I use the same spoon to stir to aerate. I don't sanitze that spoon because I figured it's in the boil but when I think about it the entire spoon is not in the boil and more of the spoon gets submerged when I'm stirring it in the bucket. I'll try sanitizing the entire thing next time before I aerate.
For cool down I put the kettle in an ice bath in the tub. I use individual gallons of distilled water. I save the last two gallons and put them in the freezer. I let the wort cool in the ice bath for a little and then use the almost frozen distilled water to bring the temperature down.
I'm not really looking forward to getting new buckets. :/ I have two fermenters and a bottling bucket. I know they are not a lot of money but I have trouble justifying to my wife getting anymore stuff. haha
I assumed this was an infection because it looks exactly like the last batch which did have a sour flavor. This one however does not have any sour flavor yet. Actually since it's a cider it wouldn't be bad if it did.
If I can't figure this out I'm just going to dive into wild brewing completely since I seem to be doing a good job of it!ha
Here is a link to my homemade bottling/fermenting buckets, and my system. I have since figured out that I can ferment 4.75 gallons in one of those, and I never get any sediment because I have placed the spigot a 1/4 inch or so higher than a bottling one is normally, that allows me to tilt the bucket if I need to and still not get any trub.
https://www.homebrewtalk.com/f11/bottling-closed-system-homemade-fermenter-spigot-428255/
When your wort is cooling, is there a lid on the pot? Lots of bugs in the air.