(snippage) Who cares if they are a huge club? They had the most points, so they win.
Of course that would be true, IF they were a Club, but they definitely are NOT.
I had to leave the Banquet early to get our beers ready to pour at the Tiki Room for the stampede that began the minute the Banquet ended. So I didn't hear the HCOTY announcement.
And it is total horse****.
CLUBS have REGULAR meetings, bylaws or a charter of some kind, and events. Many CLUBS hold regional competitions, which further the hobby. CLUBS also hold preparatory classes and host BJCP Exams, without which the NHC would be impossible.
CLUBS have people working to further the hobby, to educate new brewers and further the education of old brewers. My CLUB is the oldest club in the country, I'm in my 11th year on the Board of Directors, and I can tell you that a real CLUB has a core of volunteers that put in a lot of time between meetings, tastings, etc, and THAT is the kind of CLUB that the award was originally intended to recognize. Now, my club has not been in serious contention for the COTY for many years, we just don't have that many people entering the NHC, but that's besides the point.
The BNA is fun, entertaining, etc, and I know several guys like Push and Jamil that have been big BNA proponents, but the BNA NOT A CLUB.