From what knowledge I have in travelling, and some of the descriptions they provided ("coffee shop known for a vast array of syrups - toffee anyone?!?!" *insert giggles for dramatic effect*), it definitely seems this is a list more of popularity than coffee.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/best-coffee-shop-each-state_us_56981428e4b0b4eb759dd15e
Anyways, have any of you tried any of these "Best Coffee Shop..." coffees?
The Indianapolis one was easily worth a stop for breakfast, but I don't remember the coffee being anything great...