You lost a point on appearance? Generally that's an automatic 2/3 or 3/3 points for everyone unless your beer has the color and consistency of motor oil.
1/3 on appearance, and 6/10 on overall impression with yet more mention (complaint) about the color as reason. Also said something like "go easy on adjunct grains or leave out." I'm still not sure he was judging my beer that day.
It was brilliantly clear and bottled from the keg, too.