Redemption 95% Rye is very unique and very good - it doesn't follow the same profiles as most other ryes I've tried. To me, it has a new american oak flavor which works wonderful with the spicy rye.
Rye Whiskys that I love:
Sazerac 18 year (stellar!)
Thomas Handy (VERY good, and will kick your ass!)
Van Winkle 15 year (rustic, deep, old wood, vintage leather, spicy, very good)
Whistlepig (it's good; it's sweet; it's the least rye-y of the bunch but an easy drinker)
Angel's Envy 95% Rye (fuc*ing amazing, BUT you'll be thinking of rum the whole time you're sipping)
High West Rendezvous Rye (I like this better than Double Rye; it's well balanced; spicy; lightly sweet; good sipper)
Ryes you shouldn't waste your money on for sipping:
Old overholt (mixing only)
Mitchters Straight Rye (weak rye whisky and expensive)
Pi (it's okay but not worth the money)
Knob Creek Rye (it's okay but I'd spend my money elsewhere)
That's all that's popping into my head at the moment.