I guess I'll be the dissenting opinion here and say:
I love it as it is, and think you should only tweak it, not completely redo it.
I would not replace the guy, and I would not make him angry. I'd probably make the eye a bit larger, but not enormous.
What I would do is up the brightness of the highlights on the beer mug somewhat, and increase the letter spacing of "HOMEBREW" just a little bit.