phoenixs4r
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jun 16, 2011
- Messages
- 1,566
- Reaction score
- 93
Not sure where to post this... sorry if in wrong forum.
Did anyone else enter this? My brewing buddy entered in one of the best beers I had along with 3 of his own, and they all did bad according to the judges.
Perhaps I am a wee bit bitter, however it seems as though the judges were pretty unprofessional. I have 1 sheet that ranked a beer pretty low, and under each category of judging he marked 1/whatever with no notes. The side section that listed whether or not they were actually a bjcp judge was blank on a few forms, with simple initials on the name column. Is that the norm?
Again this was my first beer entered, but not theirs and they've won a few 1sts and 2nds on smaller competitions.
Maybe my brew did suck but I'm more disappointed at the lack of notes.
Did anyone else enter this? My brewing buddy entered in one of the best beers I had along with 3 of his own, and they all did bad according to the judges.
Perhaps I am a wee bit bitter, however it seems as though the judges were pretty unprofessional. I have 1 sheet that ranked a beer pretty low, and under each category of judging he marked 1/whatever with no notes. The side section that listed whether or not they were actually a bjcp judge was blank on a few forms, with simple initials on the name column. Is that the norm?
Again this was my first beer entered, but not theirs and they've won a few 1sts and 2nds on smaller competitions.
Maybe my brew did suck but I'm more disappointed at the lack of notes.