yeah, they gave it a c-, but it's actually a pretty good beer. i just did edwort's haus pale over the weekend, it may be similar. i was just looking for a decent pale. i have brewed a baltic porter (twice), a foreign extra stout, ipa using noble hops, an amber ale (twice). my favorite is a toss up between the Baltic and the FES. maybe i will like edworts haus pale and make it my standard recipe when i do a pale ale.