I'll go ahead and throw this out there too. All of the few batches I have done I've just had at room temperature, say 67-68 degrees. That's air temp. I don't have the stick on thermometer on the fermentation bucket so I can't really say what the temp of the beer was. That being said, I can't complain about any of the beers I've made. They have all been quite good. Not saying great, but I have definately enjoyed them. It sounds like, from what i've read, that if I hold the abiant temp down to say 62-63 that will get the fermentation temp at a more desireable level and improve the final outcome. Should I really expect great things and a noticeable difference by investing in the temp control? I don't think I want to hassle with the bucket of water and ice cube thing. If I'm going to do it I don't want to monitor it all the time. In the summer, my basement is usually around 67. In the winter probably 55 or so. So really there is only a 3 or 4 months where it is really an issue.
Thinking aloud.....Thoughts??? I welcome your opinions.