Way too sweet

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Firstnten

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 29, 2008
Messages
382
Reaction score
7
Location
Aberdeen NJ
5lbs Brown sugar
3 lbs molasses
OG 1.112

current SG 1.010

It's way too sweet. The air lock stopped bubbling about a week ago.

In a fit of possible stupidity I pitched another packet of yeast last night.

What am I looking at here? having this dry out nicely or having five gallons of garbage. Did I make a mistake in throwing more yeast in there because after I did it I thought to myself I should have waited. :confused:
 
What type of yeast did you use. Without checking , I figure you have to be near 14%. Perhaps your yeast can't tolerate that alcohol level. Don't toss it out. You can always blend it with another batch. We've all made batches that don't turnout as we wish.
 
What type of yeast did you use. Without checking , I figure you have to be near 14%. Perhaps your yeast can't tolerate that alcohol level. Don't toss it out. You can always blend it with another batch. We've all made batches that don't turnout as we wish.

The first pitch was White labs Champagne yeast. I was under the impression it was tolerant up to 18%. Second toss was red star Champagne. The room temp dropped under 60F one night I forgot to leave the space heater on. Maybe it cold crashed?
 
So are there any other suggestions? Should I wait it out. Should I goto a secondary tonight?


Buller...

Buller...


(sigh)..
 
Well it can be hard to get a yeast working when there is already 14% alcohol. Most of the time you need to step the yeast up slowly instead of putting them in a high sugar environment to start. You can also just pitch a massive amount of yeast to get it going.

Pitching another pack of yeast was not a bad idea, but you may need to rehydrate a couple packages of yeast, and then get the temperature at the higher end of their range so they can work better.

Otherwise you may end up blending it, or sending it to me as I love sweet cider ;)
 
So was there apple juice used in this at all or just sugar? And what is your volume that you tried to ferment? If I assume this to be 5 gallons of juice with these sugar additions then yes, there is almost no way around it being too sweet. It also probably tastes like rocket fuel right now. If you are trying to eek out more alcohol then I would recommend making a starter with the champagne yeast and then adding in some yeast nutrient to the fermenter when you pitch the starter back into it. You need to keep a mix like that above 70 degrees to keep it warm and the yeast working hard for you. Try swirling it and if that does not work rack it to a carboy and that might get your fermentation restarted. Do some more research on the mead forum also, they work with very high sugar and alcohol issues in there all the time. A lot of the advice above is from mead making and my own experience in the subject. Give all this a try and see what you can't make work on this.
 
. The air lock stopped bubbling about a week ago.

The airlock stopped but was there still tiny little bubbles running up the sides of the carboy?? I ask because one on my batchs stopped bubbling, but I still had activity in there. I waited it out a couple more weeks and the SG was still dropping down slowly. Did you add nutrients when you re-pitched it?
 
So was there apple juice used in this at all or just sugar? And what is your volume that you tried to ferment? If I assume this to be 5 gallons of juice with these sugar additions then yes, there is almost no way around it being too sweet. It also probably tastes like rocket fuel right now. If you are trying to eek out more alcohol then I would recommend making a starter with the champagne yeast and then adding in some yeast nutrient to the fermenter when you pitch the starter back into it. You need to keep a mix like that above 70 degrees to keep it warm and the yeast working hard for you. Try swirling it and if that does not work rack it to a carboy and that might get your fermentation restarted. Do some more research on the mead forum also, they work with very high sugar and alcohol issues in there all the time. A lot of the advice above is from mead making and my own experience in the subject. Give all this a try and see what you can't make work on this.

Thanks!!! Yes 5 gallons of fresh pressed. I raised the room temp and will try two packets (primed) with yeast nutrient after a few day at the higher temp. I was worried I screwed up big time with the temp drop.
 
The airlock stopped but was there still tiny little bubbles running up the sides of the carboy?? I ask because one on my batchs stopped bubbling, but I still had activity in there. I waited it out a couple more weeks and the SG was still dropping down slowly. Did you add nutrients when you re-pitched it?

It's in a bucket fermenter. It doesn't look like any bubbles are comming up and it sure doesn't have that feel when you drink it. Just real flat and real sweet.
 
Well it can be hard to get a yeast working when there is already 14% alcohol. Most of the time you need to step the yeast up slowly instead of putting them in a high sugar environment to start. You can also just pitch a massive amount of yeast to get it going.

Pitching another pack of yeast was not a bad idea, but you may need to rehydrate a couple packages of yeast, and then get the temperature at the higher end of their range so they can work better.

Otherwise you may end up blending it, or sending it to me as I love sweet cider ;)

Too bad you live in Ill. I would have given it to you at this point. Thanks for the advice!
 
Thanks!!! Yes 5 gallons of fresh pressed. I raised the room temp and will try two packets (primed) with yeast nutrient after a few day at the higher temp. I was worried I screwed up big time with the temp drop.

If that fail, dilute it with some water, or a lot of apple juice (divide it between two fermentors). It should restart under 72 hrs.
 
If that fail, dilute it with some water, or a lot of apple juice (divide it between two fermentors). It should restart under 72 hrs.

The airlock started bubbling again after the room temp went up from the second pitch of yeast. I have not been able to keep up on everything. My wife had an ectopic preg that ruptured so it has been a hectic past 5 days but shes ok now but it was a close call.

I'll get back on top of this stuff sometime next week. i have an open primary and two that need togo into the secondary now.

I don;t know how many people from NJ are on this website but NEVER GOTO BAYSHORE COMMUNITY HOSPITAL.....
 
What you are making is more of an apple wine than an apple cider. When you get into that high of alcohol contents it can take quite some time for fermentation to finish. I usually let my fruit wines sit in the primary for a week or so until fermentation has slowed and then move to a glass secondary where fermentation will often continue for a month or more.

Not to mention with 17% alcohol you will want to let it age for a minimum of 6 months, maybe closer to a year.

Anyway to answer your question it should still be fine. Just move it to a secondary and forget about it for a long time.
 
What you are making is more of an apple wine than an apple cider. When you get into that high of alcohol contents it can take quite some time for fermentation to finish. I usually let my fruit wines sit in the primary for a week or so until fermentation has slowed and then move to a glass secondary where fermentation will often continue for a month or more.

Not to mention with 17% alcohol you will want to let it age for a minimum of 6 months, maybe closer to a year.

Anyway to answer your question it should still be fine. Just move it to a secondary and forget about it for a long time.

After all of the feed back here and on other MB's after I move it to the secondary I was going to let it sit for six months then bottle it and let it sit untill late sept october before trying it.

What do you think?
 
I pulled a glass out of this batch this past weekend. It's still cloudy but what a difference in taste. Have not done a SG reading. Going to put it in a secondary soon.

I have to say the molasses is the way to go it tastes 1000% better then brown sugar alone. I'm thinking of a honey and molasses mix soon.
 
Update:

I don't have a graduated cylinder or anything that will work with my hydrometer while using a carboy. So this weekend I poured off a 1.5 liter bottle and took a reading (SG1.000-002). the cyder is still dark. After the reading i corked the bottle and let it sit for 48 hours. Within that time allot of sediment had appeared so I opened it. It seemed pretty clear that I would have had a bottle bomb had I not done so from the "pop" i got while opening it. Any guess as to how long it will take before this clears?
 
Might take some time to clear after repitching. Did you use pectic enzyme at all? that helps to clear in fresh-pressed juice, but it's not instantaneous. Time is usually all you need. You can always cold crash when it reaches the gravity you want & it should clear pretty quick then. I'd let it bulk age at least till it's clear before bottling; but then I've bulk aged things for a few years in carbouys. That's my 2 cents worth, GF.
 
Update:

I don't have a graduated cylinder or anything that will work with my hydrometer while using a carboy. So this weekend I poured off a 1.5 liter bottle and took a reading (SG1.000-002). the cyder is still dark. After the reading i corked the bottle and let it sit for 48 hours. Within that time allot of sediment had appeared so I opened it. It seemed pretty clear that I would have had a bottle bomb had I not done so from the "pop" i got while opening it. Any guess as to how long it will take before this clears?

i would guess at normal temps your looking at at least 2-3 weeks of clearing. I fyou drop it below 40F then you will clear alot faster and alot of that extra yeast you pinched in will drop out of solution. but you wont ferment anymore. Likely as it is at 1.002-1.000 then its decently dry, but all the unfermentable sugars you used in the molasses and the brown sugar your sill gonna have a sweet flavor, more of the taste of molasses. It sounds like good suff. If you do this again to shoot for a high ABV then i would sugest using one type of Champagne yeast and trying to use honey instead of molasses. This stuff is gonna stay dark, it wont ever lighten unless you set it in the sun for a week after youve bottled it and let UV scrubb some of the color, but then youll get off flavors in the bottle. Were you planning on carbing this??? i mean youve got somthing like dark apple champagne here, definatly not cider.

cheers
 
i would guess at normal temps your looking at at least 2-3 weeks of clearing. I fyou drop it below 40F then you will clear alot faster and alot of that extra yeast you pinched in will drop out of solution. but you wont ferment anymore. Likely as it is at 1.002-1.000 then its decently dry, but all the unfermentable sugars you used in the molasses and the brown sugar your sill gonna have a sweet flavor, more of the taste of molasses. It sounds like good suff. If you do this again to shoot for a high ABV then i would sugest using one type of Champagne yeast and trying to use honey instead of molasses. This stuff is gonna stay dark, it wont ever lighten unless you set it in the sun for a week after youve bottled it and let UV scrubb some of the color, but then youll get off flavors in the bottle. Were you planning on carbing this??? i mean youve got somthing like dark apple champagne here, definatly not cider.

cheers

Not sure on carbing this. It wasn't an option when I first started the batch but I ordered a 2 keg system the other day. I also ordered 2 beer extract kits but I guess I could hold off on one. I also picked up a 250ml Graduated cylinder so no more SG issues. The taste at this point is good IMO but I'm thinking of waiting until the SG drops under 1.000 before bottling or keging. This stuff has been going since 11/26 which I guess in not that long...
 
Might take some time to clear after repitching. Did you use pectic enzyme at all? that helps to clear in fresh-pressed juice, but it's not instantaneous. Time is usually all you need. You can always cold crash when it reaches the gravity you want & it should clear pretty quick then. I'd let it bulk age at least till it's clear before bottling; but then I've bulk aged things for a few years in carbouys. That's my 2 cents worth, GF.

I didn't use anything besides Yeast and sugar. Yeah I have seen your posts you have the patients of a saint. I think before you told me to get a pipeline going LMAO!! Thats what I'm shooting for. As much as I want to start drinking this stuff I'm going to pour off one more bottle and then as you guys say "forget about it".

On a side bar: I have a batch of 80% apple and 20% cranberry juice going. I saw that you had tried different percentages of cranberry to apple before only to have it come out tasting like cough syrup. If you are right I'll drink that green to get ride of it and make room.
 
I didn't use anything besides Yeast and sugar. Yeah I have seen your posts you have the patients of a saint. I think before you told me to get a pipeline going LMAO!! Thats what I'm shooting for. As much as I want to start drinking this stuff I'm going to pour off one more bottle and then as you guys say "forget about it".

On a side bar: I have a batch of 80% apple and 20% cranberry juice going. I saw that you had tried different percentages of cranberry to apple before only to have it come out tasting like cough syrup. If you are right I'll drink that green to get ride of it and make room.

Some people love their "cranapple ciders," there are plenty of posts in the "Better Than Apfelwein" thread with people saying how good theirs is, Maybe you'll love yours. My taste experiments were just for me & may not apply to someone else's tastes. As far as getting a "pipeline going," I don't think I'm the one who said that, but it not a bad idea. Regards, GF.
 
Update on this batch gravity is at 1.000 and I made the stupid mistake of bottling it before it completely cleared. I assumed that is was as dark at it was because of the molasses. I was wrong lees is forming on the bottom of the bottles and it's now starting to clear....

I suck....
 

Latest posts

Back
Top