Assembled my control panel - element always on

I assembled my Control Panel per P-J's diagram: http://www.pjmuth.org/beerstuff/images/Auberin-wiring1-a4-5500w-30a-e-stop.jpg

When I turn on the CP and select the correct element, it just goes full boar. Regardless of what the settings on the PID are. I have the red hot wire controlled by the SSR. The LED on the SSR blinks when the out light on the PID blinks.

I brewed like this, but I am going to be brewing again on Sunday and I would like to have a functional control panel. Any ideas whats wrong?

Faulty SSR? How do you know it is full power?

Do both element do the same thing? If only one does, maybe you tapped that element to the line side of the SSR?

I built a PJ box last year and I had the same issue, 40% throttle PID output and 100% element heating no matter what I did. I swapped in a new 40a ssr (using a 5500w element in HLT and in BK), and it works like a charm now.

Sidenote: I didnt have the first SSR properly cooled either, now I have the auber heatsink bolted on and it is cool to the touch. I am thinking now that I may have faulted the ssr early on with overheating. (it eventually melted down hence the replacement)