Brand New it's about $500 so you be the judge.
I'd say teh 2nd one for $65 less and a CO2 tank with reg is the better deal.
But. in comparison, I got a chest for $125, tanks for $100 (brand new can be found much cheaper) and a reg for 50. So that's $275 for everything brand new. Hold's 3 kegs, but had to build a tap box. Not a horrible deal IMO for a plug N Play, but you can make a kegerator much cheaper if you like DIY