Two schools of thought:
1.) Put tons of honey in the fermentor to start with, more than the yeast can eat, and wait for the alcohol to get high enough where the yeast die out. This leaves behind some of that initial honey you put in unfermented, and therefore sweeter mead. Downsides are it makes a hell of a powerful mead (some aren't into that) and it takes a long time to age out that hot alcohol flavor. The benifit is that it makes a hell of a powerful mead (some are into that
) and requires less tending and maintainance.
2.) Put in a decent amount of honey, enough to hit your gravity and alc by vol (whatever that might be) and let it ferment dry. Age it for a little bit, maybe cold condition it if you can, and make the residual yeast drop out. When it is clear, heat to sanitize some additional honey and add it to the carboy to taste, dialing in your desired sweetness level. The benifits are a lot more control, over alcohol (lower abv means less aging required) and sweetness. The downside is you have to pay attention, and tend your mead more than the traditional way.
As far as carbonating, both have downsides. Usually the danger with bottle carbing mead is that the yeast can simply keep working until the mead gets dryer, overcarbed, and possibly explosive. Most who have carbed mead use champagne bottles with cages over the cork. However if you use the right amount of yeast during bottling (i.e. a little bit) it will simply carb your mead and die out. If you use too much, well just be careful opening them
Personally I like the second approach, mostly because I like variety (and not control, as some would say). With the second approach I can leave some dry, make some semi sweet, some very sweet, and I can choose to carb or not carb each one. Out of one batch, without adding anything other than honey, I just made four or five different meads.
Sorry for the keyboard diarreah. Too much Great Divide Hercules Double IPA. Whoo! Has anyone had this stuff? Its great for long winded posts!
mike
mike