If you like, pick up all three (or even all four, and include "mineral water") from your local store and try them side by side. I can easily tell the difference between "mineral water", and the other two plain carbonated waters easily, as mineral water a) isn't always carbonated and b) often has a SUBSTANTIAL mineral content (there's a German brand, Gerolsteiner, that I enjoy that's ~1800ppm alkalinity or something like that). Club soda and seltzer are a little tougher. But the quinine makes tonic water taste completely different than the other three. Quinine is very bitter, and to balance tonic water often has a lot of sugar added as well. If you've tried making a gin and tonic with seltzer instead of tonic water, you'll know why it doesn't work.