I kept reading about how "some find Comet's 'wild American' character offputting," so I decided to give it a try myself, as a fan of both wildness and offputtingness!
9 lb. 2-row
1 lb Crystal 15
1 lb Rye Malt
.5 oz Simcoe, 60 min
1 oz Comet, 20 min
1 oz Comet, 5 min
1 oz Comet, flameout
1 oz Comet, dry hop 7 days
1 pkg US-05
This was a 5 gallon BIAB batch, with around 77% efficiency. Mashed at 152°.
NOTES: So, this is definitely a powerful hop -- despite using pretty much my standard APA additions, it's got the aroma and taste of many of my IPAs. I would say the flavor and aroma are most like Chinook, with very heavy grapefruit zest, but also a good bit of pineapple, and a trace of soapiness. A really nice beer, although I find myself following it up with something a bit more subdued rather than another pint of the Comet. The beer never quite cleared -- probably a combination of the rye and some chill haze. I'd brew this again, although I might back down the bittering addition to keep the IBUs around 40-45 instead of the 52 this one came out to.
9 lb. 2-row
1 lb Crystal 15
1 lb Rye Malt
.5 oz Simcoe, 60 min
1 oz Comet, 20 min
1 oz Comet, 5 min
1 oz Comet, flameout
1 oz Comet, dry hop 7 days
1 pkg US-05
This was a 5 gallon BIAB batch, with around 77% efficiency. Mashed at 152°.
NOTES: So, this is definitely a powerful hop -- despite using pretty much my standard APA additions, it's got the aroma and taste of many of my IPAs. I would say the flavor and aroma are most like Chinook, with very heavy grapefruit zest, but also a good bit of pineapple, and a trace of soapiness. A really nice beer, although I find myself following it up with something a bit more subdued rather than another pint of the Comet. The beer never quite cleared -- probably a combination of the rye and some chill haze. I'd brew this again, although I might back down the bittering addition to keep the IBUs around 40-45 instead of the 52 this one came out to.