This is by far my favorite brewday of the year, probably due to the ridiculousness that we seem to always attempt.
Last year, the frog and I made a wheat, a pumpkin, a spiced ale, a small beer, and the namesake barleywine, Fall Down Ale 002.
The small beer, and I believe the pumpkin, both won awards in a local competition. Chaos and disorder, (not to mention drunkeness), sometimes yield great results!
I can't even recall what everyone else brewed, but we did have a damn good time. I'll have to see if I can find the pictures from last year.