I definitely got to a point where all beers of a style tasted exactly the same: either hoppy and bitter (pale ales) or sweet and creamy (imperial stouts). Stupid palate fatigue.
So more than praising some beers, I have to express disappointment in having tried Dark Lord. I also tried it with vanilla and from bourbon barrels. With all the hype it receives, I thought it would be more... special. Instead, it reminded me of a hoppier version of, say, Central Waters' imperial stout. Good beer to be sure, but it didn't match my expectations for it.
I really liked Smokey the Beer and Rendezvous (from Lakefront).