I don't particularly care about wasting water or wasting energy making ice. That wasn't my point at all. I'm refuting the statements from the people who claim they save water by using ice. I'm simply suggesting that ice is not necessarily a MORE eco friendly nor penny pinching alternative to just running straight tap water. Again, I'm not being a hippie here. I personally choose to reuse the waste water from chilling in some additional way because it's easy.
I pay less than a penny per gallon for tap water so when it's cold enough to do the chilling job on its own, I go that route. That's 30 cents to chill a 6 gallon batch. If you do this with ice, it will require about 40 pounds and I think that it's going to cost more than 30 cents to make it or buy it.