Beer isn't a race, it's an adventure.
Another perspective on craft beer cost. At $40 for a 5-gallon home-brew kit, it would cost $1.00 USD per pint. At $5/pint at your local brew pub, instead you could afford a $200 kit and make your own for the same cost per pint. On the extreme end, at $12/pint, that would be a $480 home-brew kit. I'll sell these for 50% off and you could save BIG MONEY!!
I cringe when I go to a local brew pub and pay over $5 for a drink that I wouldn't even submit for a competition.
I am not much of a new beer finder either but thankfully the liquor store a half mile from my house has weekly beer tastings so I get to try a lot of different beers without forking over extravagant six pack prices in search of unicorn beers.I've been trying to explain why I don't constantly try new stuff in hopes (mostly vain) of finding an exceptional beer. The quote above says it all.
Since the odds of finding the next exceptional beer are low, for me to live in pursuit of it is nothing more than, to paraphrase @Bilsch , "wasting my time drinking meh beer."
THAT is why I prefer to drink things I know I like, as opposed to chasing what, to me, are unicorns. Others may have different goals, interests, and tastes, and that's fine. Good thing, in fact--imagine if we were all the same, how that would end up.